My Pet Toy Story – A Hidden Danger

Pet Toy Dangers

Are Pet Toys Safe? What the Latest CPS Report Reveals About Hidden Dangers

By Lindsey Wolko, Founder & CEO, Center for Pet Safety

Years ago, before I founded Center for Pet Safety, little Madison joined my family. She was a tiny English Cocker Spaniel with the waggiest tail and the sweetest disposition.

My other dogs weren’t quite sure what to make of her, so to help her feel included, I bought a cute pink poodle toy that included an attached rope. I hoped the toy would spark playtime and ease her transition into our home.

She gently took the toy from my hand. Seconds later, I turned around to find blood all over the floor. I grabbed the toy, tended to her mouth, and was shocked at how such a small moment had turned into a crisis.

That afternoon, I took the toy apart, and what I found was disturbing. Inside of the body of the toy, the components were held together with a zip tie cut at a sharp angle, creating a razor‑edge. That hidden zip tie had carved up the inside of Madison’s mouth.

From that day forward, I became wary of every product I brought home for my pets. And as I began interviewing pet owners from around the globe, I learned Madison’s story was far from unique.

Thousands of pet owners have shared their product experiences with CPS. Stories of shock, anger, heartbreak, and staggering veterinary bills. Many reached out to manufacturers or retailers only to be dismissed, blamed, or offered nothing more than a replacement toy. Some were told outright that the injury or death of their pet was “100% their fault.”

These stories, and the lack of accountability behind them, are among the primary reasons why Center for Pet Safety exists.

What Our New Pet Toy Report Reveals

Center for Pet Safety (CPS) has released a new, data‑driven report showing that pet toys are now the top manufactured product linked to injury and death reported to our nonprofit. This is a multi‑billion‑dollar category with no required testing, no recalls, and no injury reporting.

Our findings show:

  • Indigestible toy materials, such as rubber, nylon, plastics, plush fabrics, stuffing, wire, batteries, small parts, are causing life‑threatening GI obstructions.
  • Emergency care often costs $4,000–$8,000, and many pets do not survive.
  • Flavorings and scents added to indigestible materials encourage unsafe chewing.
  • Digestible treats paired with indigestible holders confuse pets and increase ingestion risk.
  • “Indestructible” toys are a myth, because poor quality control means many break down during normal play.

These injuries are preventable. But without regulation, pet owners are left to navigate these risks alone.

Resources Pet Owners Can Use Today

To help families protect their pets, CPS created two new tools designed to reduce risk immediately:

1. CPS Safer Choice

An independent, data‑backed resource featuring safer product lists for high‑risk categories like pet toys. Center for Pet Safety’s Safer Choice helps pet owners identify products that reduce the likelihood of injury or emergency care.

2. Pet Toy Risk Guide Infographic

A clear, easy‑to‑use visual guide showing:

  • What materials and design features to avoid
  • How certain toy types create hidden hazards
  • What pet owners can do right now to make safer choices

These resources exist because pet owners deserve transparency, and because no family should experience what Madison and I did.

Protecting Pets Starts With Awareness

Madison’s injury was preventable. So were the injuries and losses experienced by the families who shared their stories with us. The Pet Toy Report is a call to action for pet owners, veterinarians, retailers, and responsible manufacturers.

If you’d like to learn more about the Pet Toy Report, CPS Safer Choice, or the Pet Risk Guide infographic, contact us at Info@CenterForPetSafety.org or 800‑324‑2659.

Together, we can make playtime safer and protect the pets we love.

* * * * *

Turn to Center for Pet Safety for Trusted Guidance

Center for Pet Safety (CPS) is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit dedicated to protecting companion animals and the people who love them. As the independent voice for pet owners, we advance pet safety through evidence-based research, testing, and education. Learn more and support us!

Strategic Partnership Opportunities

Join leading organizations and foundations — Volvo Trucks, Subaru, Wells Fargo, Johnson Controls/Adient, Beaird Family Foundation — in scaling our mission.
PAWS UP for Safety-Center for Pet Safety

More Articles